Do larger objective size and increased magnification add up
to better performance? Mike Alibone took Kowa’s new XD44 binoculars into the
field to find out.
Price: £896 (8.5x44); £970 (10.5x44)
Size: 165x138 mm (both)
Weight: 950 g (8.5x44); 965 g (10.5x44)
Field of view (m at 1,000 m): 122 m (8.5x44); 108 m
(10.5x44)
Close focus: 1.7 m (both)
Gas-filled: yes (both)
Waterproof: yes (both)
Guarantee: 10 years (both)
If the top end of the optics market needed a shake-up, Kowa
has stepped in to provide one. Hot on the heels of its flagship fluorite
crystal 88 mm telescopes, the TSN-883/884 (see Birdwatch 174: 44) comes the
XD44 series binoculars, which use the optical technology of the TSN-880/770
series scopes with Prominar XD lenses.
Launched in February this year, this new series follows the
trend of the latest roof-prism binoculars to feature larger objective lenses –
in this case 44 mm – and increased magnification, to 8.5x and 10.5x. This
aside, these very understated binoculars will win no prizes on the catwalk of
optical aesthetics. Essentially two smooth, uncontoured, green rubber-armoured
barrels linked by a hinge and central focusing knob, they are uninspiringly plain
and would completely lack identity were it not for the small Kowa logo on the
distal hinge cover. Anyone would think Kowa is intent on keeping its new baby a
secret, but closer inspection reveals the Prominar brand epithet inset along
the left barrel.
It is difficult to imagine why the XD44s have made their
debut almost incognito. Could it be their weight, perhaps? Just short of a
kilogram, they are the heaviest performance binoculars on the market and, at a
time when optics manufacturers are placing an emphasis on weight reduction, it
seems strange that Kowa appears to be bucking the trend with these models. But
another Japanese manufacturer has done something similar: having introduced a
series of models widely recognised as being ‘too heavy’, it rapidly reduced
their weight by 20 per cent and released a ‘lite’ version within a year of the
launch of the original models. Perhaps history will repeat itself.
What the XD44s may lack in style and agility, they make up
for in performance. Despite being fairly heavy, they are perfectly balanced
when held for viewing. The usual niceties of nitrogen gas filling, virtually
indestructible barrels and an ultra-close focusing system, taken for granted in
contemporary binoculars, are all present here. Soft but firm rubber eye-cups
click-stop in four different positions to vary eye relief, although if you want
to operate the dioptre, you have to position the cup on the right barrel at one
level above the base setting. I found the single-eye focusing mechanism very sensitive
in terms of reaching the correct setting and achieving parity for my eyes.
The central focusing knob is generously proportioned,
allowing a comfortable two-finger contact to be made with the high-friction
surface. In the two models I tested, there appeared to be a considerable
difference in how freely the knobs turned (the 8.5x had a smoother action),
although this may be the result of variation between the individual
instruments. In just under 1.5 turns the focusing ranges from close-up to infinity
in both models, but I found a discrepancy between the manufacturer’s
close-focus figure of 1.7 m for each model and the figures I achieved, which
were closer to 1.8 m for the 8.5x and 2.0 m for the 10.5x.
A positive feature of the focusing is the admirable depth of
field. Switching from objects which are in focus between 4 m and middle or long
distance to distant horizon takes a quarter turn of the knob on both
binoculars, although the depth of field is not quite as great on the 10.5x
model.
The field of view for each is close to those of other
top-flight models on the market. Given the ‘extra’ 0.5x magnification of the
10.5x, the 108 m field at 1,000 m is excellent, but the equivalent 122 m for
the 8.5x is perhaps a little lower than might have been expected.
The image itself did not fail to impress. The colours,
contrast, sharpness and brightness are excellent, and in this respect these
binoculars are a joy to use. Their brightness alone – no doubt a combination of
the high-quality glass in the lenses and the new prism system and coatings –
propels them towards the top tier of optical excellence. With larger than
‘standard’ objectives gathering more light, the 10.5x magnification in
combination with the 44 mm objectives provides the same exit pupil as a 10x42
binocular. I particularly liked the extra reach provided by this magnification
compared with the currently popular 8x magnification. In poor light conditions
(dusk at a busy mixed Common Tern and Black-headed Gull colony) both models
performed incredibly well, utilizing what little daylight remained to produce
an enhanced image. To my eyes, there was no significant difference between the
two in terms of brightness.
Other aspects of the image include a bluish colour cast,
producing a generally cold tone, and a minimal degree of chromatic aberration.
Although detectable, the latter is restricted to the periphery of the image,
where the curvature of field is similarly nominal and the reduction in
sharpness is negligible.
There is no doubt that these two models are excellent.
Although the XD series is competitively priced compared to other top-drawer
binoculars, it seems likely it will have to overcome its weight problem before
‘Kowa power’ fully penetrates the highest echelons of binocular supremacy.
|